Abstract

The rapid growth of battery energy storage and electric vehicles has increased lithium demand and intensified the attention given to the environmental performance of alternative extraction pathways. Conventional life cycle assessments (LCA) of lithium production typically report midpoint indicators in physical units, which limits cross-category comparison and reduces their usefulness for economic and policy analysis. This study presents a comparative monetized LCA of lithium carbonate equivalent (LCE) production from three pathways: solar brine evaporation, hard-rock spodumene mining, and geothermal brine recovery. Using the TRACI 2.1 midpoint results reported in a prior LCA, six impact categories—global warming, smog formation, acidification, respiratory effects, carcinogenic toxicity, and non-carcinogenic toxicity—are converted into monetary values through a benefit-transfer, damage-cost approach. Total environmental external costs are estimated at USD 11.85/kg LCE for solar brine evaporation, USD 9.45/kg LCE for spodumene mining, and USD 4.11/kg LCE for geothermal brine recovery (all USD amounts are expressed in $2025 unless otherwise mentioned). Smog formation contributes more than 80% of the total monetized damages across all pathways, while toxicity-related impacts account for a smaller share than implied by the normalized midpoint results. Monetization changes the relative ranking of the solar brine and spodumene pathways, while indicating that geothermal brine recovery has the lowest monetized external cost among the impact categories evaluated. These findings show that monetized LCA can complement conventional midpoint assessment and provide more decision-relevant insights for policy and economic evaluation.

IPC Classification

Keywords